Tyler Alvarez Gay or Girlfriend and Shirtless Photos. Ever since her imaginary TV boyfriend Nev Schulman (of MTV’s Catfish) tied the knot a few months ago, our friend Deena has been looking for a new “imaginary nerdy boyfriend” to replace the now married TV host. Last night, Deena called us to say that she found a new imaginary beau in the person of Tyler Alvarez. Check him out. He’s a nerd alright and is a worthy replacement of Nev. Hehe.