Jimmy Tatro Gay or Girlfriend and Shirtless Photos. We mentioned in our earlier post that our friend Deena has found an imaginary nerdy beau in the person of Tyler Alvarez, well we also found a new imaginary beau. As it happens, our imaginary TV boyfriend comes from the same show as Tyler. He ain’t a nerd though. In fact, he is more of a frat boy. Famewatchers, say hello to Jimmy Tatro, the star of American Vandal which — considering the buzz its been receiving since its release — is turning out to be the latest hit on Netflix.